The Lismullen Hurdle: Oscar Dan Dan Wins but makes no Impression on World Hurdle

The Grade 2 Lismullen Hurdle ran last weekend at Navan saw a good race take place, but the outcome gave very few clues as to likely success stories for the Cheltenham Festival. The race was won by the Thomas Mullins trained, Oscar Dan Dan, but the manner of victory left a little to be desired, particularly as he had looked like losing until the 7/4 race favourite, Aitmatov fell at the last.

Oscar Dan Dan always seems to run well at this time of the year but it is not sure whether he will be challenging yet for honours at Cheltenham although he does hold an entry for the Grade 1, World Hurdle, a race where he finished in 6th place in 2009, 18 lengths behind winner, Big Bucks. To date that run was his only attempt for Cheltenham glory.

His next race will almost certainly be the Grade 1 Hatton’s Grace Hurdle at Fairyhouse in early December, a race he won last year by a neck from Ninetieth Minute after finishing extremely strongly and a race that has proven a good guide for Cheltenham in the past, boasting such outstanding winners as Brave Inca and Istabraq.

Aitmatov, who won this race in 2009 has never really fulfilled his promise becoming more synonymous with inconsistency more than winning races. He has had plenty of chances over the years but like Oscar Dan Dan his one attempt at the Cheltenham Festival, finishing sixth behind the formidable Inglis Drever in the 2008 World Hurdle. His biggest success to date in a long career was his win in the 2007 Hatton’s Grace.

Second home on Sunday was the Edward O’Grady trained, Jumbo Rio, who ran with some promise, but seemed to find the 2 mile four furlong trip on the difficult side. However he is only a 5 year old and will improve as the season progresses. He was aimed at the Champion Hurdle last year at Cheltenham, but was outclassed, finishing down the field, 23 lengths adrift of the winner, Binocular.

Binocular and Big Bucks are still to make their seasonal reappearances but both are antepost favourites for their Cheltenham targets, the Champion Hurdle and World Hurdle respectively. Binocular is likely to be first seen this season in the Grade 1 Fighting Fifth Hurdle at Newcastle at the end of November, while Big Bucks is likely to follow the same pattern as last season and be aimed at the Grade 2 Long Distance Hurdle at Newbury, also at the end of November.

Kauto Star back in ascendancy following pleasing return to Racing

Any Kauto Star detractors were soon put in their places after the multi grade one winner, comfortably  regained the JNWine.com Champions Chase at Down Royal on November 6th; a race he last won in 2008.

Making his first appearance since his horrific fall when attempting to win the Cheltenham Gold Cup for a third time in March, Kauto Star could not have been more impressive. He jumped at his best, took up the running when the timing was right and finished in style to win by four lengths from 2010 Arkle Trophy Chase winner, Sizing Europe, with China Rock a neck further back in third place.

The performance was testimony to the training skills of Paul Nicholls and his team at Ditcheat, who have worked wonders on the four times King George Chase winner after his death defying fall, four fences out at Cheltenham. He won this race at Down Royal in a style reminiscent of an imperious Arkle, covering every move made by the rest of the field, until jockey, Ruby Walsh decided it was time to take up the initiative.  Once in front he was never headed and won with plenty in hand, suggesting that he will improve considerably next time out.

Henry de Bromhead, trainer of Sizing Europe was happy with the performance of his 8 year old, particularly as he proved that he can stay a 3 mile trip and perhaps longer. He clearly needed the run last time when only a seven length second behind China Rock in the Grade 3 Star ‘Best For Racing Coverage’ Chase over 2 miles 7 furlongs at Punchestown two weeks previously. He avenged that defeat of course at Down Royal and according to De Bromhead he will improve again, before possibly taking Kauto Star on again in the King George at Kempton on Boxing Day.

The first target for Kauto Star of course this season is to win what would be a record breaking fifth King George, thus eclipsing the great Desert Orchid, who won it four times and was second once in a five year period. However, he is down to run in the Grade 1, Betfair Chase at Haydock on the 20th November, a race he won in 2009, defeating 2010 Cheltenham Gold Cup winner, Imperial Commander by a nose in an epic race. That said Nicholls might decide to miss the ‘Betfair’ this year in favour of heading straight to Kempton to take on Imperial Commander there, he had his latest rival a distance behind him last year and there is no reason why a similar outcome would not ensue this time around. He also features in the betting for the Hennessy but it’s difficult to imagine both him an Denman heading to Newbury and the next time we see Kauto I think will be when looking to justify favouritism once again in the King George odds.

Sadly for all connected with Kauto Star, they will not have the mercurial, Ruby Walsh on board at Kempton and possibly not even at Cheltenham after he broke his right leg in two places following a later fall at Down Royal on Saturday. Early reports indicate that Walsh will be out of action until at least the early part of next year, which has led to Bookmakers opening a market for which jockey will take the ride on Kauto;  Tony McCoy has been made the favourite to be that man at overwhelming odds of 1/4 with Jonjo O’Neil and JP McManus, for whom he is a retainer, unlikely to stand in his way of a tilt at being the man to guide Kauto home in the King George and Cheltenham Gold Cup.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.